Compatibility Issues May Delay Ethereum's Glamsterdam Upgrade Until May 2027

Compatibility Issues May Delay Ethereum's Glamsterdam Upgrade Until May 2027

Following outreach to more than 50 impacted organizations, Ethereum's development team is considering modifications to gas pricing proposals that may cause disruptions to current smart contracts.

According to deliberations at Thursday's All Core Developers meeting, Ethereum's upcoming Glamsterdam upgrade may face delays extending as late as May 2027 should developers choose to revise its specifications in response to smart contract compatibility challenges.

Glamsterdam represents a planned hard fork for Ethereum designed to enhance the network's efficiency and capacity. Nevertheless, security firm ChainSecurity issued a warning in October indicating that proposed modifications to Ethereum's gas pricing mechanisms could cause disruptions to existing smart contracts and potentially create vulnerabilities for exploitation, leading developers to delay the Hoodi testnet fork that was initially set for Oct. 26.

The compatibility challenges revolve around gas repricing proposals identified as EIP-8037 and EIP-8038. In October, researchers discovered 13 real-world instances of contracts that could potentially be affected, while an investigation conducted in November analyzed eight smart contract invariants that the upgrade might disrupt.

At Thursday's meeting, developers revealed that the Ethereum Foundation, along with ChainSecurity and security firm Dedaub, had reached out to a minimum of 50 companies whose operations could be affected. The team classified three projects as having high-impact concerns, with remediation efforts either completed or anticipated by mid-December, whereas medium-impact projects indicated timelines stretching to Jan. 10.

The development team discussed whether to maintain Glamsterdam's current specifications or implement modifications aimed at minimizing compatibility risks, acknowledging that alterations designed to safeguard certain contracts might simultaneously create problems for others.

Every spec change could, again, break new invariants that we are not aware of breaking yet.

Proceeding with the current specifications, mainnet activation could occur as soon as mid-January 2027. Nevertheless, postponing a decision until January might delay activation to late February or early March, or potentially April or May should modifications be implemented, and no final determination has been made at this time.

Ethereum weighs accelerating post-quantum security

In a separate matter, Ethereum's subsequent planned hard fork, known as Hegotá, may experience a reduction in scope as the network aims to expedite its migration to post-quantum cryptography.

Throughout the meeting, developers discussed potentially deferring certain Ethereum Improvement Proposals in order to give priority to post-quantum features, though multiple participants contended that narrowing the upgrade's scope would provide minimal advantages unless it simultaneously accelerated the deployment schedule.

Developers additionally expressed compatibility concerns regarding EIP-8151, a proposal crafted to safeguard accounts transitioning to post-quantum security. An initial review uncovered what could be a substantial number of existing smart contracts that might be impacted by these modifications, adding complexity to the proposal's potential inclusion in Hegotá.

No final decision was made concerning Hegotá's scope, with client teams anticipated to present their positions in advance of continued discussions scheduled for two weeks from now.