Brothers acquitted in $25M Ethereum MEV fraud case as judge dismisses charges

Brothers acquitted in $25M Ethereum MEV fraud case as judge dismisses charges

Two brothers walked free after a federal judge dismissed fraud charges in a $25 million Ethereum MEV case, determining prosecutors couldn't establish fraudulent misrepresentation in their trading tactics.

Two brothers facing federal charges for allegedly siphoning $25 million from Ethereum trading bots were acquitted by a US federal judge, who determined that the government's case lacked sufficient evidence of material misrepresentation during the purported exploit.

Judge Jessica Clarke issued her ruling on Monday, dismissing wire fraud and associated charges against Anton and James Peraire-Bueno. The government's case centered on allegations that the brothers, both educated at MIT, took advantage of a vulnerability in maximal extractable value (MEV)-boost software during April 2023 to manipulate sandwich-trading bots into executing transactions they subsequently interfered with, capturing $25 million in roughly 12 seconds.

According to the judge's determination, the executed transactions failed to meet the threshold of false promises or represent criminal fraud, emphasizing that the proceedings were not concerned with evaluating the ethical dimensions of the defendants' conduct or whether alternative legal violations may have occurred.

The case had previously gone to trial, resulting in a mistrial during November 2025 after the jury proved unable to unanimously agree on a verdict.

Peter Van Valkenburgh, who serves as executive director at Coin Center, characterized the acquittal as "excellent news," warning that the prosecution's honest validator theory created a dangerous precedent that would have enabled government authorities to enforce their own behavioral standards upon Ethereum validators using wire fraud statutes as the mechanism.

Anyone participating in an open network would have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their behavior 'dishonest' and haul them into court.

Peter Van Valkenburgh, Coin Center executive director

Judge Clarke's ruling additionally referenced a 2025 case involving trader Avraham Eisenberg and the Mango Markets incident, in which another judge similarly determined that evidence of false representations proved inadequate.